Translations

Translations of Don Quixote

22 translations are recorded on readers.place.

These are the translated editions we hold records for. A translation we have not catalogued is missing from this list, not from the world.

This book in English

Tobias Smollett 6 printings we hold · 1999–2005 · Barnes & Noble Classics
Walter Starkie 5 printings we hold · 1957–2003 · Mentor
John Ormsby 3 printings we hold · 2005–2015 · Anglo Didactica
Charles Jarvis 2 printings we hold · 1992–1998 · Oxford University Press, USA
Edith Grossman 2 printings we hold · 2003 · Ecco
Thomas Shelton 2 printings we hold · 2004 · Kessinger Publishing, LLC
J. M. Cohen 1 printing we hold · 1951 · Penguin Classics
Samuel Putnam 1 printing we hold · 1978 · Modern Library
P. A. Motteux 1 printing we hold · 1993 · Wordsworth
Burton Raffel 1 printing we hold · 1996 · W. W. Norton & Company
Dominick Daly 1 printing we hold · 1999 · Core Knowledge Foundation
John Rutherford 1 printing we hold · 2003 · Penguin Classics
Tom Lathrop 1 printing we hold · 2006 · European Masterpieces in Translation

This book in a language our records do not name

Walter Starkie 4 printings we hold · 1957 · Signet
John Rutherford 4 printings we hold · 2001–2003 · Penguin Books Ltd
Edith Grossmann 2 printings we hold · 2004–2005 · Secker & Warburg
J. J. A. Goeverneur 1 printing we hold · 2016 · CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform

This book in Portuguese

Daniel Augusto Gonçalves 2 printings we hold · 1999 · Livraria Civilização Editora

This book in Spanish

John Ormsby 1 printing we hold · 2005 · Anglo-Didacto
Tobias Smollett 1 printing we hold · 2005 · Blackstone Audiobooks

This book in HRV

Iso Velikanović 1 printing we hold · 2004 · Globus media

This book in Russian

N.M. Li Łubimova 1 printing we hold · 2005 · Izd-vo AST

What we found when we looked into it

Written by a person, from the sources listed at the end. Where critics disagree, this says so rather than picking a winner. It is not a catalogue record and does not claim the same authority as the table above.

Researched 2026-08-18. PD rule as above.

Translations

Translator Year Publisher/Imprint Copyright status In print?
Thomas Shelton 1612/1620 — PD (US) No (historical interest only)
Pierre Antoine Motteux 1700 — PD (US) Not independently verified
John Ormsby 1885 — PD (US) Yes — the standard free/PD edition
Samuel Putnam 1949 Viking In copyright Not independently verified
J.M. Cohen 1950 Penguin Classics In copyright Not independently verified
Burton Raffel 1995 Norton Critical Edition In copyright Yes
John Rutherford 2000 Penguin Classics In copyright Yes
Edith Grossman 2003 Ecco/HarperCollins In copyright Yes

Reception

  • Comparative survey per the Oxford Guide to Literature in Translation and Ilan Stavans's assessments, as digested by welovetranslations.com, accessed 2026-08-18 (independent comparison blog, citing named scholarly sources): Shelton "conveys a good deal of Cervantes' tone" but has passages "clearly not understood" and "signs of haste"; Ormsby is the "most genuine, closest to the original" per Stavans, though "not always easy" due to archaic diction; Putnam is an "exemplary piece of work" but criticized as "pedantic," "almost incomprehensible" by some reviewers cited; J.M. Cohen is "accurate enough" but "decidedly flat" and "fairly lifeless"; Raffel is "excellent," achieving "syntactic tracking" in natural colloquial American English.
  • Edith Grossman (2003): Carlos Fuentes, in The New York Times Book Review (novelist/critic, professional literary stature, no commercial stake in Grossman's edition), called it "a major literary achievement." Harold Bloom (literary critic, wrote the introduction to this specific Ecco edition — disclosed interest: he is part of the package he's praising) called Grossman the "Glenn Gould" of translation, praised "the extraordinarily high quality of her prose," and wrote that "the Knight and Sancho are so eloquently rendered by Grossman that the vitality of their characterization is more clearly conveyed than ever before." — writerswrite.com and bookcritics.org (National Book Critics Circle), both accessed 2026-08-18.
  • Comparative consensus per the same welovetranslations comparison (2022): "Grossman is recommended if you want the funniest, most readable version that still feels literary"; "Rutherford is recommended if you want maximum fidelity to Cervantes's wordplay, puns, and linguistic jokes plus excellent scholarly notes"; "Grossman seems the most preferable translation closely followed by Rutherford," with the caveat that "Grossman is the trendy one" — i.e., its dominance is partly a function of visibility, not a unanimous critical verdict.

Parallel excerpt

A first attempt to quote Ormsby's opening line was caught and discarded in this research pass — an initial fetch produced a plausible-sounding but unverified paraphrase ("In a village of La Mancha, the name of which I have no desire to recall, there lately lived a gentleman of the old-fashioned sort, such as are wont to amass collections of arms, old bucklers, lean horses, and greyhounds"), which did not match the actual Ormsby text once independently cross-checked against a second source. The version below is the one verified against Wikisource's transcription of the Ormsby edition and is the one to use.

John Ormsby (1885), public domain, US — source: Wikisource, Don Quixote/Volume 1/Chapter I (transcription of the Ormsby translation; translator confirmed independently against the title page of Project Gutenberg #996, gutenberg.org/files/996/996-h/996-h.htm), verified 2026-08-18. Part I, Chapter I, opening:

"In a village of La Mancha, the name of which I have no desire to call to mind, there lived not long since one of those gentlemen that keep a lance in the lance-rack, an old buckler, a lean hack, and a greyhound for coursing."

Licensing: Public domain in the US.

Motteux (1700) and Shelton (1612/1620) are also PD but their exact text was not independently re-verified against primary sources in this pass — do not quote without direct verification.

Decision guide

Sources map cleanly onto a real tradeoff, not just a popularity contest: Grossman for the funniest, most fluent literary read (backed by Fuentes and Bloom, though Bloom's praise is disclosed as coming from inside the same edition's front matter); Rutherford for maximum fidelity to Cervantes's wordplay and the strongest scholarly apparatus, per the same comparison that ranks Grossman first; Ormsby for the best free/PD option, at the cost of archaic 1880s diction; Raffel for readers who want natural colloquial English with less interpretive flourish than Grossman. The honest caveat to carry onto the page: multiple sources note Grossman's dominance is partly visibility/marketing ("the trendy one"), not an uncontested critical sweep — Rutherford is "praised, but not as widely or loudly."

Sources

Back to the book